Under the now-scrapped rule, if a buyer believed their home was worth $1.5 million and rejected a written offer of $1.3 million, their agent could not advertise the property for anything less than $1.3 million.
Even if the seller later realised their expectations were too high and wished to adjust their asking price, the agent would not be able to change the advertised price.
Real Estate Institute of NSW CEO, Tim McKibbin, said the rule would mean buyers would not know that a property had become more affordable.
"It misleads and disadvantages those purchasers and it certainly disadvantages the vendor," he said.
He said real estate agents had been warning the government that the legislation could backfire.
"We made clear that this wouldn't work out in the market [and] we were ignored," he said.
The premier said he had received negative feedback from real estate agents in his own electorate.
"I do think it's unforeseen, but it is something we're going to have to deal with," Mr Minns said.
"A deteriorating real estate market may mean that you rejected an earlier offer, but in actual fact, you'll take it a month later.
"Particularly if it's a distressed sale."
Reform reversal
With just a few days of parliament left for the year, the government is not expected to make any legislative amendments to pause the controversial changes.
Instead, it is expected to issue a regulation that would have the same effect.
Also being put on hold will be the requirement for agents to advertise a selling price, or price range, for properties.
Fines of up to $110,000 for underquoting will also be delayed, while the government reassesses the full suite of changes.
The reversal of key reforms will be a significant blow to Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong, who is facing a separate preselection battle in his seat of Macquarie Fields.
Mr Chanthivong said the laws had been passed "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market".
"People are already doing it tough, and the last thing we want is for laws designed to protect home buyers to inadvertently make it harder for them to buy a home," he said.
Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James said the government should have designed laws that could withstand a property downturn.
"Property prices move in cycles," he said.
"The law needs to be able to meet the dynamics of the market at any given point in time."
article by state political reporter Nick Dole